Trout Fishing in America, The Pill versus the Springhill Mine Disaster, In Watermelon Sugar
New York: Delacorte Press/Seymour Lawrence, 1969
112/108/138 pages; ISBN 1-1997-8543-1; First printing September 1969
Hard cover, with dust jacket.
Facsimile reprints of
Trout Fishing in America,
The Pill versus the Springhill Mine Disaster, and
In Watermelon Sugar in the manner of their original editions, including front cover photographs and title pages. Front cover photograph by
Edmund Shea of Michaela Clark LeGrand, Brautigan's daugher
Ianthe, and Brautigan. LeGrand also appeared with Brautigan on the front cover of
Trout Fishing in America. Back cover is blue with the word "mayonnaise" centered in white. Blue titles on front cover and spine. These same treatments are repreated on front and back dust jacket. Includes a review for each book.
Not only was this the first combined edition of any of Brautigan's works, it was also the first hard cover edition of
Trout Fishing in America. Publication of this collection resulted from a report by Kurt Vonnegut of Brautigan's West Coast popularity. Delacorte negotiated with Four Seasons Foundation to publish these three books. Three hundred thousand copies sold during the first year of publication.
Promotional Materials

Quarter-page advertisement
Black and white
5" x 7"
Rolling Stone 1969
Reviews
In addition to the specific reviews detailed below, the novels in this collection may also be included in
General Reviews of Brautigan's work and his place in American literature. They were also each reviewed separately at the time of their original publication. See each novel for specific reviews.
Anonymous. "Trout Fishing in America, The Pill versus the Springhill Mine Disaster, In Watermelon Sugar."
The New York Times Book Review 7 June 1970: 2, 38.
The full text of this review reads
Republications in one volume of three works by an experimental writer of extraordinary comic perception. "This is an important publication without the desolating tedium of recent literary 'importance.' These books are fun to read."
Reprinted
The New York Times Book Review 6 December 1970: 102.
Davenport, Guy. "C'est Magnifique mais Ce N'est pas Daguerre."
Hudson Review 23 (1) 1970: 154-161.
Reviews several works, including Brautigan's.
READ the full text of the reference to Brautigan.
Feld, Michael. "A Double with Christina."
London Magazine August/September 1971: 150-152.
A negative review of both Brautigan and his works.
London Magazine, a bimonthly arts journal, featured poetry, articles, fiction, arts, and reviews. This issue also included a discussion of John Cage and Indeterminacy by Roger Sutherland, poetry by Sylvia Plath, and fiction by Elaine Feinstein. The cover art accompanied an article titled "Notes on the Decline and Fall of Indian Clothing" by Nirad Chaudhuri. This issue ran to 160 pages and was edited by Alan Ross.
READ the full text of this review.
Maillard, Keith. "Trout Fishing in America, The Pill versus the Springhill Mine Disaster, In Watermelon Sugar."
Broadside/Free Press (Cambridge, Massachusetts) 9 (5) 22 April 1970: 8.
READ the full text of this review.
McGuane, Thomas. "An Optimist vis-a-vis the Present."
The New York Times Book Review 15 February 1970, Sec. 7: 49.
READ the full text of this review.
Reprinted
Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 12. Ed. Dedria Bryfonski. Detroit: Gale Research Company, 1980. 57-74.
Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 1. Ed. Carolyn Riley. Detroit: Gale Research Company, 1973. 44-45.
Morris, Desmond. "Books of the Year: A Personal Choice."
The Observer [London] 21 December 1969: 17.
Authors briefly describe the books they liked best from the year 1969. Morris notes
City Without Words, a collection of poems by W. H. Auden,
Groupie by Jenny Fabian and Johnny Byrne, and Brautigan's collection.
The full text of the reference to Brautigan reads
The most extraordinary literary discovery of the year for me was a young San Francisco writer, Richard Brautigans [sic], whose three-books-in one entitled Trout Fishing in America, The Pill Versus the Springhill Mine Disaster, and In Watermelon Sugar (Delacorte Press) will, I am told, shortly be published in this country. If I describe Brautigans [sic] as a hippie-surrealist, you will probably want to run a mile, but don't; his quirky, meandering fantasies are a delight, and I predict a major impact when he appears here.
READ the full text of this review.
Reprinted
Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 12. Ed. Dedria Bryfonski. Detroit: Gale Research Company, 1980. 57-74.
O'Hara, J. D. "Happier (but Not Holier) than Thou."
Chicago Tribune Book World 11 January 1970: 3.
READ the full text of this review.
Parumba, Arthur. "Richard Brautigan's 3 & 1 & 3 in 1 Books."
The Fifth Estate [Chicago] 4 (16) 24 December 1969: 17.
READ the full text of this review.
The full text of this review reads
Originally published separately by Four Seasons Foundation in San Francisco and later in paperback by Dell (1969), these avant-garde works now popular with college students are amusing and readable. The two novels are reminiscent of Kenneth Patchen's The Journal of Albion Moonlight (Assoc. Bks., 1968) in their delineation of freaky people in an extraordinary world. Life and love are treated with uninhibited imagination, often engendering unexpected similes (". . . a roll of toilet paper, so old it looked like a relative, perhaps a cousin, to the Magna Carta"). The Pill versus the Springhill Mine Disaster, a volume of selected poems, abounds in surrealistic humor and startling earthiness. A good addition to large fiction collections.
Reprinted
Library Journal Book Review 1970. Ed. Judith Serebnick. New York and London: Sowker, 1970. 703.
Walters, Richard. "Trout Fishing in America, The Pill versus the Springhill Mine Disaster, and In Watermelon Sugar."
Masterplots 1970 Annual. Ed. Frank N. Magill. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Salem Press, 1970. 56-62.
Brautigan is not the promising young writer of the year. . . . He [does not take] his writing seriously. . . . He is artlessly irreverent . . . wildly funny. . . . He blasphemes the continuing traditions of American literature . . . defies the timeless enigmas of man, and shuns the proper, proven subjects and characters. . . . So it is difficult to proceed, unarmed as we are, with no convenient facts to gird our loins, with little literary reputation to take up and guide our venture, with no syllabus for another school of humor. [Brautigan emerges as a humorist.] Brautigan, if he is hailed for anything, will be known for his comedy—pure and simple.
READ the full text of this review.
Reprinted
Survey of Contemporary Literature. Revised Edition. Ed. Frank N. Magill. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Salem Press, 1977. Vol. 2. 883-889.

New York: Houghton Mifflin, 1989
112/108/138 pages; ISBN 0-395-50076-1; First printing 1 March 1989
Paperback, with printed wrappers.
Front cover photograph by
Erik Weber of Brautigan and Michaela Clark LeGrand which first appeared on the front cover of the first edition of
Trout Fishing in America.
Back cover is red with the word "mayonnaise" centered in white.
Reviews
In addition to the specific reviews detailed below, the novels in this collection may also be included in
General Reviews of Brautigan's work and his place in American literature. They were also each reviewed separately at the time of their original publication. See each novel for specific reviews.
Ketchum, Diane. "Counterculture Classic: Richard Brautigan, A Whimsical Muse of Spirit of the '60s." The Tribune [Oakland, California] 5 April 1989: D1, D2.
Reviews Keith Abbott's
Downstream from Trout Fishing in America and Brautigan's collection.
"If Richard Brautigan had lived only four years longer, he would have enjoyed his own revival as a legend of the '60s." Says the collection of
Trout Fishing in America, The Pill versus the Springhill Mine Disaster, In Watermelon Sugar celebrates the publisher's twentieth anniversary of their first publication of the individual novels. Provides anecdotes about Brautigan in San Francisco during the 1960s. Says
Trout Fishing in America
transcends its interest as a hippie period piece. With its deadpan tone and sustained metaphor of the search for an unspoiled trout stream, it has its place in the tradition of American fiction, as successor in sentiment of [Henry David] Thoreau and Mark Twain.